Skirmish in Doubtful Canyon...

5fish

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jul 28, 2019
Messages
10,700
Reaction score
4,554
Skirmish in Doubtful Canon, Steen's Peak, the New Mexico Territory, where the Yankees are attacked by Apache Indians while en route from Fort Cummings to Fort Bowie. The Federals report killing 10 and wounding another 20 more Apaches.


snip...


The Skirmish in Doubtful Canyon took place on May 3, 1864 between a company of infantry from the California Column and a band of about 100 Apaches. The fighting occurred near Steins Peak in Doubtful Canyon, Arizona Territory. Doubtful Canyon, along with Apache Pass in Arizona and Cookes Canyon, in New Mexico was a favored location for an ambush by the Apache along the Butterfield Overland Mail route.

The Californians were on the march from Fort Cummings to Fort Bowie in the military District of Arizona, when they were attacked in the canyon.[1] The band of Apaches were defeated by fifty-four men of Company I, 5th California Volunteer Infantry Regiment under Lieutenant Henry H. Stevens.[1] The skirmish lasted about an hour, until the Apache fled. The Apache lost 10 killed, 20 wounded. The Californians lost one missing, five wounded according to official records.[2] Michno claims the battle lasted almost 2 hours and that the Californians suffered 6 wounded, (1 mortally), 1 missing presumed killed


along with Apache Pass in Arizona and Cookes Canyon, in New Mexico was a favored location for an ambush by the Apache along the Butterfield Overland Mail route.

The Californians were on the march from Fort Cummings to Fort Bowie in the military District of Arizona, when they were attacked in the canyon.[1] The band of Apaches were defeated by fifty-four men of Company I, 5th California Volunteer Infantry Regiment under Lieutenant Henry H. Stevens.[1] The skirmish lasted about an hour, until the Apache fled. The Apache lost 10 killed, 20 wounded. The Californians lost one missing, five wounded according to official records.[2] Michno claims the battle lasted almost 2 hours and that the Californians suffered 6 wounded, (1 mortally), 1 missing presumed killed
 

5fish

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jul 28, 2019
Messages
10,700
Reaction score
4,554
Here is an ambush the Apaches won.... same place... read the link to see the torture the Apaches handed out....


snip...

In late April, Giddings' party was ambushed 'just at dawn of day, as they were approaching the station at Steins Peak.' Cochise and his Apaches killed nine men, but reserved the worst torture for those captured alive.

snip...

Mesilla Times of May 11, 1861, reported what happened: 'Nine men are missing, and it is feared have all been massacred although there exists some hope that some of them may be retained as prisoners. The Savages inflicted upon some of their victims a horrible torture, and exhibited a refinement in cruelty unparalleled in the catalogue of Indian barbarities.
 
Last edited:

5fish

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jul 28, 2019
Messages
10,700
Reaction score
4,554
The Giddings party was a stagecoach robbery.... WE can get rich... I now wonder if it was really Apaches... Were Apaches known to torture people they captured....

Today ranches exist along the narrow privative road through Doubtful Canyon.
In the 1860’s the Butterfield Overland Stage route went through the canyon.
Apache Raiders made passage through the canyon very ‘DOUBTFUL!’
In April 1861 the Giddings’ Party was ambush near Steins Peak stagecoach station.


snip... How much gold was taken...

Between $28,000 and $30,000 (much more in today’s dollars!) of company assets in Gold as well as likely other valuables in the strong box.

snip...

STORY: In 1861, a group of Texans, among them John Giddings of the Butterfield Stage Overland Stage Line, were taking company assets West to the California office. They stayed overnight at Stein’s Station, and headed the next morning into the aptly-name Doubtful Canyon, where they were ambushed and slain. The massacre site is only about 1 mile West of Stein’s Station, and their bodies were found two days later by other travellers.
 
Top